Does the factory antenna unscrew and then that little stubby one screw in its place? I don't listen to the radio, so it doesn't really matter if the stubby gets worse reception. As long as it fills the spot there and looks like it kinda belongs. :biggrin:
The Scott Drake one is slightly different to the factory one. The factory one has 4 screws that screw into the front fender from under the chrome cover. The Scott drake one has a screw clamp under the rectangle base that holds the base to the fender from inside the fender.
The Scott drake one unscrews from the base. the factory one that I had in my car that was broken at some point does not look like it will unscrew.
I have been running with a screw as a antenna delete. Following this thread I was motivated to purchase a short antenna to test and have for my Carlisle trip. I found one at O'Reilly. At this point I am going more for how it works rather than looks. I think the issue is that I still have the antenna base which is chromed and then this antenna that is rubber, which looks goofy.