I used a starter from DB Electrical on my 351C. At the time it was about $45 shipped. Turned a 10.5:1 engine over no problem.
If you have a manual transmission with 164 tooth flywheel, you need their 3223
Shop for the Ford F Truck Bronco 4.9L 300 6Cyl Starter 1965-1996 3223 410-14033 at DB Electrical. The best selection, low prices, fast shipping, and great customer service.
www.dbelectrical.com
If you have a manual transmission with 157 tooth flywheel, or any automatic, you need their 3205
Shop for the Ford Bronco 4.9L 5.0L 5.8L Starter 92 93 94 95 96 at DB Electrical. The best selection, low prices, fast shipping, and great customer service.
www.dbelectrical.com
If you prefer to get one locally, the application for the 3223 is a 95 F-150 w/5.8L & manual trans, the 3205 is the same, but with auto transmission.