Carb Selection for 302

7173Mustangs.com

Help Support 7173Mustangs.com:

This site may earn a commission from merchant affiliate links, including eBay, Amazon, and others.

RocketFoot

Stangin' ain't easy but somebody gotta do it!
Staff member
Administrator
Moderator
Joined
Jul 2, 2010
Messages
5,325
Reaction score
428
Location
Latrobe, PA
My Car
1971 Mach 1
Hey guys...I am getting ready to buy a new carb and I am leaning toward a Holley Brawler but I need to figure a few things out before I buy...

Ford Small Block 302 (306 with 289 heads)

Manual or electric choke?

Spread bore or square bore?

600cfm or 650cfm?

Vacuum or mechanical secondaries? This is the important one...I'm not sure what I'm looking for to see what I need!

This is the one I kinda like...hopefully if fits my 302!
https://www.amazon.com/BRAWLER-CARB...mzn1.fos.c3015c4a-46bb-44b9-81a4-dc28e6d374b3
 
You running a manual or auto transmission? I like Mechanical Secondaries on a manual transmission, vacuum for an auto. I prefer an electric choke but that is my preference. As far as 600 or 650 cfm will come down to tuning and what your running for a cam. Spread bore will help with low end drivability a little as well as in-town fuel econ. What are you running for an intake?
 
Thats how holley recommends it, too. Vacuum secondaries for automatic cars. I prefer electric choke cause its 1 less thing to deal with.
 
The carb needs to work well with the rest of the build. Cam, compression, gear ratio, auto or standard, stall speed, usage, etc. Pay for adjustability as no two builds are the same. The minimum is adjustable jets, air bleeds, and idle channel restrictors. adjustable power valve restrictors are nice but, not usually needed. Unless you are a carb "guru" adjustable emulsions bleeds are not needed. If vacuum secondary, the screw type adjustment is very handy. If you want the carb to feed from the driver's side the primary bowl needs to be threaded on both sides. If a mild build, a 600 carb is more than enough and a vacuum secondary is a better fit than mechanical secondaries. Chuck
 
I'll have to post some photos of my setup...I didn't build the engine so I'm not sure what all has been done to it other than the PO said it was bored out to be a 306 had 289 heads for higher compression or something. Sorry, I'm more of a diesel engine guy, LOL!

The transmission is an auto. I'm hoping photos will help because it is already set up, I just need to replace an old Autozone Holley rebuild that seems to have a bent butterfly rod or bad choke or something...it won't open! I'm also pretty sure it has an electric choke, but it has been a while since I've been under the hood! I'll get some pics after work and post them tomorrow morning...maybe someone can see what I got going on here!

LOL...I found an old post from when I started kicking the idea of a new carb around! (It's been like 3 or 4 years but there was a new house and covid and whatever else life stuff that kept me from it!) But this is the carb that I have now...

https://www.summitracing.com/parts/hly-65-80457#overview
So, it looks like square bore with vacuum secondaries would be the best bet! I'll confirm with pics tomorrow!!
 
Last edited:
My two cents, but first you have gotten some really good suggestions with the prior respondents, nothing I would disagree with or take with a grain of salt (or two). Here is the web address for Holley's carb selector tool. Be sure to fill in the cubic inches and maximum redline at the top, then select the options below those entry fields. When you click the See Results button you will be presented with an array of possible carbs.

As for your more specific questions re: features, my first response is to get vacuum secondary carb, especially if you decide to get a carb a little larger than recommended for your engine displacement and maximum redline. It is hard to not fall prey to the temptation to get a larger carb than recommended. With vacuum secondaries the rear throttle blade set will only open when it get a vacuum signal indicating the engine can handle more A/F mixture. And, you will be likely to get a bog on heavy, WOT acceleration.

I like square holes vs Spreadbore holes. I have heard arguments on both sides of the fence, and for me it is a matter of practicality when it comes to being able to get more common parts.

I also vote in favor of electric chokes. But, be aware the White wire with a Black stripe feeding the stock/oem carburetor choke cap terminal is NOT 12 volts DC current (assuming it is the stock 2100 two barrel carb with electric choke). The after market carbs, to include Holley, "require" a 12 volt switch DC current to power the electric choke, which means a little repairing for you to do. Nothing bad or difficult, but if you get this wrong you will end up with a choke that will open too slowly or incompletely, which will result in fuel fouled spark plugs and puffing black smoke out your exhaust as the engine warms up. It is not hard to clear out fuel fouled spark plugs once the A/F ratio is stabilized, but you could end up with a speeding ticket when doing so.

There are few "correct" ways to get 12 volts of switched power to the electric choke, and several incorrect ways. I will cover a few of the more common incorrect ways I see occur - provided so you do not end up doing something that looks right, but are wrong:
  • The first one I mentioned above is using Circuit #4 (White wire with Black stripe) being used on the factory carb electric choke cap. The problem is Circuit #4 is powered directly from the alternator stator terminal. It only produces power when the alternator is truning and outputting current for the battery and electric accessories. The problem is the stator voltage is about 1/2 of alternator output voltage, inadequate for a system requiring 12 volts. The other issue, which is a lesser issue, is the stator output is AC current, not DC. You do not want to use AC current on devices designed for DC use. For electric chokes they re durable enough to work with either AC or DC current, but the voltage is too low for the Holley carb, hence the choke opening will be too slow and/or not open enough.
  • The next incorrect way to provide current to the electric choke cap terminal is to tap into one of the smaller terminals on the Starter Relay. The smaller terminals are marked with an "S" (Start) on one, and "I" (Ignition) on the other. The terminal I see folks use for 12 volt switched current is the "I" terminal. The problem is when the engine is running the "I" terminal is powered by the ignition coil's voltage from the ignition switch. The reason that is a problem is the ignition wire leading to the positive terminal on the coil, and to the "I" terminal on the Starter Relay, is coming through a resistor wire, where the voltage is less than 12 volts despite being DC current. As with the Stator current, the voltage is too low to let the choke as fast or as far as it needs to. But, I have seen lots of folks do it that way, and it seems to work okay. It just is not working like it should.
There are three ways I like to use to get full voltage switched power to the choke cap terminal. But, be aware that your choke cap may have two blade terminals. One is meant to go to ground. Do not apply voltage to that terminal. The other blade terminal is the one designed to receive full battery voltage (usually stated as 12 volts, but for a car that is running the alternator will produce a little more than 12 volts). Here the ways I select from:
  • If you have a 1971 through 1973 Mustang the wiring harness provides a wire that is meant to connect to a carburetor Throttle Position Solenoid (TPS). If is powered by Circuit #640, which is a Red wire with Yellow hash marks. Your engine may or may not have a TPS on the carburetor, but either way the electrical harness near the carburetor should have a socket meant to connect to the pigtail lead for the TPS were it present. You can safely tap into Circuit #640 to use for the electric choke. I suggest tapping into the wire on the solenoid side of the connector near the carburetor to prevent altering the original wiring harness insulation.
  • As alternative connection is to tap into the Circuit #63 wire for the windshield wiper motor. That is a red wire, and I suggest you tap into the wire on the motor side of its connector, again to prevent altering the original wiring harness.
  • The third way to get 12 volts to the electric choke is to install a relay that uses with circuit #4 (stator), circuit #640 (TPS), or circuit #63 (wiper motor) as the trigger voltage to cause the relay to then send battery voltage from the positive side of the starter relay to the electric choke terminal. This is bit bit more involved than the first two options, but I have used it successfully in several cases. Using the Circuit #4 Stator current to activate a relay does work, but I really try to not use it for that purpose, simply because Circuits #640 and #63 are plenty easy to access - so why bother with the Circuit #4?
I have attached some schematic snippets for the 1971 - 1973 Mustangs for the circuits I have mentioned above. I included some schematics showing the oem Electric Choke circuits and Ignition circuits just so you can see how those are laid out, not to encourage you to use the resistor wire ignition or stator circuit to power the Holley electric choke..

I also have a few YouTube videos that you may find useful where I cover these circuits being used for an aftermarket carburetor electric choke. The video at is oriented to providing 12 volts of switched power for a Pertronix Ignition System, but you can use what is shown in the video to power the electric choke instead if you like.

The video at shows how I used a windshield wiper motor Circuit #63 to provide power to an electric choke. The only reason I did not use Circuit #640 for the TPS is because someone owned this Mach 1 before me, and either cut off the harness lead tot he TPS, or placed it somewhere I could not find. It was easier for me to just use Circuit #63 as opposed to dig through the harness to try to find Circuit #640's terminal wiring.

I think that ought to get you on track. If you have any questions you cam email me at [email protected].


Best of luck to you. And, Circuits #640 and #63 are protected with proper fusing. Circuit #4 (Stator) is not. Also, if you use a relay be sure to provide proper fusing on the load wiring between the battery voltage and the relay so any wiring you introduce is properly protected from overload...
 

Attachments

  • 1971Mustang_Circuit63_WindshieldWiperSwitchedPowerUnderHood_20211002.pdf
    1.5 MB
  • 1971Mustang_ElectricalSystems_WreColorChart_20210708.pdf
    2.7 MB
  • 1971Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_20220715_TextBoxModified re- 2-34Reference_20230201.pdf
    1.4 MB
  • 1971Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoidAndCircuit640_PertronixIgnitor-FlamethrowerCoil_20220715-2...pdf
    6.7 MB
  • 1971Mustang_WindshieldWiperMotorCircuit_20220715.pdf
    646.4 KB
  • 1973Mustang_FuseBlockCorrectedSchematicSnippet_FromKennethPattison_20220201.pdf
    33.5 KB
  • 1972Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_20220715.pdf
    3 MB
  • 1972Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_EnhancedCircuitryHighlight_20220930.pdf
    14.2 MB
  • 1971-1973_Mustang_Cougar_ThrottlePositionSolenoidCircuitSnippets_20230201+.pdf
    17.8 MB
  • 1972Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_20220715.pdf
    2.9 MB
  • 1973Mustang_AlternatorRegulatorEectricChoke_20210727.pdf
    491.7 KB
  • 1973Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_Annotated_IMG_4976.JPG
    1973Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_Annotated_IMG_4976.JPG
    2.5 MB
  • 1973Mustang_ThrottlePositionSolenoid_Circuit640_20210309.pdf
    1.9 MB
  • 1973Mustang_WiperSwitchAndMotor_20230515.pdf
    370.7 KB
  • 10023wm - 1973 Colorized Mustang Wiring_F62_WindshieldWiperMotorAndSwitch_20201121.pdf
    1.1 MB
  • 10023wm - 1973 Colorized Mustang Wiring_Page_29_IgnitionSwitchResistanceWireIgnitionCoil_20200...pdf
    187.3 KB
I also vote in favor of electric chokes. But, be aware the White wire with a Black stripe feeding the stock/oem carburetor choke cap terminal is NOT 12 volts DC current (assuming it is the stock 2100 two barrel carb with electric choke). The after market carbs, to include Holley, "require" a 12 volt switch DC current to power the electric choke, which means a little repairing for you to do. Nothing bad or difficult, but if you get this wrong you will end up with a choke that will open too slowly or incompletely, which will result in fuel fouled spark plugs and puffing black smoke out your exhaust as the engine warms up. It is not hard to clear out fuel fouled spark plugs once the A/F ratio is stabilized, but you could end up with a speeding ticket when doing so.

There are few "correct" ways to get 12 volts of switched power to the electric choke, and several incorrect ways. I will cover a few of the more common incorrect ways I see occur - provided so you do not end up doing something that looks right, but are wrong:
  • The first one I mentioned above is using Circuit #4 (White wire with Black stripe) being used on the factory carb electric choke cap. The problem is Circuit #4 is powered directly from the alternator stator terminal. It only produces power when the alternator is truning and outputting current for the battery and electric accessories. The problem is the stator voltage is about 1/2 of alternator output voltage, inadequate for a system requiring 12 volts. The other issue, which is a lesser issue, is the stator output is AC current, not DC. You do not want to use AC current on devices designed for DC use. For electric chokes they re durable enough to work with either AC or DC current, but the voltage is too low for the Holley carb, hence the choke opening will be too slow and/or not open enough.
  • The next incorrect way to provide current to the electric choke cap terminal is to tap into one of the smaller terminals on the Starter Relay. The smaller terminals are marked with an "S" (Start) on one, and "I" (Ignition) on the other. The terminal I see folks use for 12 volt switched current is the "I" terminal. The problem is when the engine is running the "I" terminal is powered by the ignition coil's voltage from the ignition switch. The reason that is a problem is the ignition wire leading to the positive terminal on the coil, and to the "I" terminal on the Starter Relay, is coming through a resistor wire, where the voltage is less than 12 volts despite being DC current. As with the Stator current, the voltage is too low to let the choke as fast or as far as it needs to. But, I have seen lots of folks do it that way, and it seems to work okay. It just is not working like it should.
In addition to all this, something else I did on my '69 was add in an oil pressure switch. It only closes to complete the circuit when there is oil pressure. Without that, if you sit around with your engine off and the key on, listening to the radio or something, your choke will be opening up when you dont need it to
 
My two cents, but first you have gotten some really good suggestions with the prior respondents, nothing I would disagree with or take with a grain of salt (or two). Here is the web address for Holley's carb selector tool. Be sure to fill in the cubic inches and maximum redline at the top, then select the options below those entry fields. When you click the See Results button you will be presented with an array of possible carbs.

As for your more specific questions re: features, my first response is to get vacuum secondary carb, especially if you decide to get a carb a little larger than recommended for your engine displacement and maximum redline. It is hard to not fall prey to the temptation to get a larger carb than recommended. With vacuum secondaries the rear throttle blade set will only open when it get a vacuum signal indicating the engine can handle more A/F mixture. And, you will be likely to get a bog on heavy, WOT acceleration.

I like square holes vs Spreadbore holes. I have heard arguments on both sides of the fence, and for me it is a matter of practicality when it comes to being able to get more common parts.

I also vote in favor of electric chokes. But, be aware the White wire with a Black stripe feeding the stock/oem carburetor choke cap terminal is NOT 12 volts DC current (assuming it is the stock 2100 two barrel carb with electric choke). The after market carbs, to include Holley, "require" a 12 volt switch DC current to power the electric choke, which means a little repairing for you to do. Nothing bad or difficult, but if you get this wrong you will end up with a choke that will open too slowly or incompletely, which will result in fuel fouled spark plugs and puffing black smoke out your exhaust as the engine warms up. It is not hard to clear out fuel fouled spark plugs once the A/F ratio is stabilized, but you could end up with a speeding ticket when doing so.

There are few "correct" ways to get 12 volts of switched power to the electric choke, and several incorrect ways. I will cover a few of the more common incorrect ways I see occur - provided so you do not end up doing something that looks right, but are wrong:
  • The first one I mentioned above is using Circuit #4 (White wire with Black stripe) being used on the factory carb electric choke cap. The problem is Circuit #4 is powered directly from the alternator stator terminal. It only produces power when the alternator is truning and outputting current for the battery and electric accessories. The problem is the stator voltage is about 1/2 of alternator output voltage, inadequate for a system requiring 12 volts. The other issue, which is a lesser issue, is the stator output is AC current, not DC. You do not want to use AC current on devices designed for DC use. For electric chokes they re durable enough to work with either AC or DC current, but the voltage is too low for the Holley carb, hence the choke opening will be too slow and/or not open enough.
  • The next incorrect way to provide current to the electric choke cap terminal is to tap into one of the smaller terminals on the Starter Relay. The smaller terminals are marked with an "S" (Start) on one, and "I" (Ignition) on the other. The terminal I see folks use for 12 volt switched current is the "I" terminal. The problem is when the engine is running the "I" terminal is powered by the ignition coil's voltage from the ignition switch. The reason that is a problem is the ignition wire leading to the positive terminal on the coil, and to the "I" terminal on the Starter Relay, is coming through a resistor wire, where the voltage is less than 12 volts despite being DC current. As with the Stator current, the voltage is too low to let the choke as fast or as far as it needs to. But, I have seen lots of folks do it that way, and it seems to work okay. It just is not working like it should.
There are three ways I like to use to get full voltage switched power to the choke cap terminal. But, be aware that your choke cap may have two blade terminals. One is meant to go to ground. Do not apply voltage to that terminal. The other blade terminal is the one designed to receive full battery voltage (usually stated as 12 volts, but for a car that is running the alternator will produce a little more than 12 volts). Here the ways I select from:
  • If you have a 1971 through 1973 Mustang the wiring harness provides a wire that is meant to connect to a carburetor Throttle Position Solenoid (TPS). If is powered by Circuit #640, which is a Red wire with Yellow hash marks. Your engine may or may not have a TPS on the carburetor, but either way the electrical harness near the carburetor should have a socket meant to connect to the pigtail lead for the TPS were it present. You can safely tap into Circuit #640 to use for the electric choke. I suggest tapping into the wire on the solenoid side of the connector near the carburetor to prevent altering the original wiring harness insulation.
  • As alternative connection is to tap into the Circuit #63 wire for the windshield wiper motor. That is a red wire, and I suggest you tap into the wire on the motor side of its connector, again to prevent altering the original wiring harness.
  • The third way to get 12 volts to the electric choke is to install a relay that uses with circuit #4 (stator), circuit #640 (TPS), or circuit #63 (wiper motor) as the trigger voltage to cause the relay to then send battery voltage from the positive side of the starter relay to the electric choke terminal. This is bit bit more involved than the first two options, but I have used it successfully in several cases. Using the Circuit #4 Stator current to activate a relay does work, but I really try to not use it for that purpose, simply because Circuits #640 and #63 are plenty easy to access - so why bother with the Circuit #4?
I have attached some schematic snippets for the 1971 - 1973 Mustangs for the circuits I have mentioned above. I included some schematics showing the oem Electric Choke circuits and Ignition circuits just so you can see how those are laid out, not to encourage you to use the resistor wire ignition or stator circuit to power the Holley electric choke..

I also have a few YouTube videos that you may find useful where I cover these circuits being used for an aftermarket carburetor electric choke. The video at is oriented to providing 12 volts of switched power for a Pertronix Ignition System, but you can use what is shown in the video to power the electric choke instead if you like.

The video at shows how I used a windshield wiper motor Circuit #63 to provide power to an electric choke. The only reason I did not use Circuit #640 for the TPS is because someone owned this Mach 1 before me, and either cut off the harness lead tot he TPS, or placed it somewhere I could not find. It was easier for me to just use Circuit #63 as opposed to dig through the harness to try to find Circuit #640's terminal wiring.

I think that ought to get you on track. If you have any questions you cam email me at [email protected].


Best of luck to you. And, Circuits #640 and #63 are protected with proper fusing. Circuit #4 (Stator) is not. Also, if you use a relay be sure to provide proper fusing on the load wiring between the battery voltage and the relay so any wiring you introduce is properly protected from overload...


In addition to all this, something else I did on my '69 was add in an oil pressure switch. It only closes to complete the circuit when there is oil pressure. Without that, if you sit around with your engine off and the key on, listening to the radio or something, your choke will be opening up when you dont need it to
Great info! Thanks guys...I didn't get the photos yet, grand daughter was here so it was tea party time! I'll post them over the weekend!
 
What is the difference between a Holley Brawler for $385 and a Holley Street Warrior for $440? They look pretty much the same?
 
I have an Edelbrock 1405 with added electric choke, 600 cfm…not the best setup for a 302. By the time you add kickdown and throttle linkage your throttle cable is out over your valve cover. There aren’t great linkage choices unless you spend big $.
 
In addition to all this, something else I did on my '69 was add in an oil pressure switch. It only closes to complete the circuit when there is oil pressure. Without that, if you sit around with your engine off and the key on, listening to the radio or something, your choke will be opening up when you dont need it to
The Switched voltage opening the electric choke when the engine is not running is aa valid concern. That is one advantage to using the stator voltgage as the stator terminal only produced power when the alternator is both operational and the engine is turning. I like your oil pressure sensor approach.
 
Back
Top