Mine had scratches and an area with a milky opaque appearance...I assume it was oxidation from where the sun was able to shine for the years it sat beside the house. I used a 3 step process and got it looking like new. First step is wet sand with progressively finer paper up to 3000 grit, then hand polish with a foam pad with a polish I used on gelcoat. Last step was another hand polish on foam pad using meguires plastic polish. I can get you specifics if you're interested in either of the polish products. I got the sandpaper from amazon. Just last weekend I did this for the 3 center gauge lenses.
Just FYI, I did this to a set of headlights some time back, and I had purchases a Turtle Wax brand kit for just this purpose....the process I outlined above is what I came up with to get satisfactory results...my point being that I don't recommend the turtle wax kit.